Posted on

RBI allows convertible notes for Startups from foreign sources

As part of policy hacks, we covered the issue of Convertible notes being recognized by Ministry of Company affairs (MCA) in our earlier blog here.

For benefit of users to start, the convertible note has been explained below.

What is a convertible note?

Convertible notes are debt instruments that converts in to equity, at a later date. The lender initially gives a loan with an understanding that he can convert these in to equity. In most cases, this later date is the date of next valuation of the company. If there is no next round of valuation, the company should return the debt back to lender in a fixed time interval.

Convertible notes are quite popular in startup ecosystems like Silicon Valley in USA.

Earlier Ministry of corporate affairs has announced acceptance of the convertible note as a concept for startups through a circular no. G.S.R. 639(E) New Delhi, dated 29th June, 2016.

The announcement by RBI is a development further to the above given MCA circular.

How does new RBI provision help startups?

Foreign investors were allowed, foreign direct investment (FDI) by way of equity and other instruments that were at par with equity e.g. compulsorily convertible preference shares/debentures. Convertibles notes were not allowed till now.

Reserve Bank of India (RBI) notification of 10 January 2017 has amended the Foreign Exchange (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident outside India) Regulations, 2000, to allow ‘Startups’ to issue convertible notes to foreign investors.

This opens new avenues for ‘Startups’ to raise funding.

iSPIRT volunteer Sanjay Khan Nagra, covers the RBI announcement on Convertible Notes here in the video below.

The complete circular is given here  on RBI website.

Other provisions in the new RBI notification explained

Convertible note has been defined in the notification

‘Convertible note’ means an instrument issued by a startup company evidencing receipt of money initially as debt, which is repayable at the option of the holder, or which is convertible into such number of equity shares of such startup company, within a period not exceeding five years from the date of issue of the convertible note, upon occurrence of specified events as per the other terms and conditions agreed to and indicated in the instrument.

Who can invest and how much?

A person resident outside India (other than an individual who is citizen of Pakistan or Bangladesh or an entity which is registered / incorporated in Pakistan or Bangladesh), may purchase convertible notes issued by an Indian startup company for an amount of twenty-five lakh rupees or more in a single tranche.

NRIs may acquire convertible notes on non-repatriation basis in accordance with Schedule 4 of the Principal Regulations.

What is a Startup?

For the purpose of this Regulation, a ‘startup company’ means a private company incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013 or Companies Act, 1956 and recognised as such in accordance with notification number G.S.R. 180(E) dated February 17, 2016 issued by the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) , Ministry of Commerce and Industry.

Govt. approval required for some sectors?

A startup company engaged in a sector where foreign investment requires Government approval may issue convertible notes to a non-resident only with approval of the Government.

Inwards remittance of amount?

A startup company issuing convertible notes to a person resident outside India shall receive the amount of consideration by inward remittance through banking channels or by debit to the NRE / FCNR (B) / Escrow account maintained by the person concerned in accordance with the Foreign Exchange Management (Deposit) Regulations, 2016, as amended from time to time.

Provided that an escrow account for the above purpose shall be closed immediately after the requirements are completed or within a period of six months, whichever is earlier. However, in no case continuance of such escrow account shall be permitted beyond a period of six months.

Convertible notes are transferable

A person resident outside India may acquire or transfer, by way of sale, convertible notes, from or to, a person resident in or outside India, provided the transfer takes place in accordance with the pricing guidelines as prescribed by RBI. Prior approval from the Government shall be obtained for such transfers in case the startup company is engaged in a sector which requires Government approval.

Compliance and reporting

The startup company issuing convertible notes shall be required to furnish reports as prescribed by Reserve Bank.

Posted on

Convertible Notes

In this session we take up another announcement by ministry of corporate affairs on convertible notes. This is a step forward to solving the problem of receiving funds as loan from foreign investors as convertible notes.

Sanjay Khan Nagra talks about the issue in the video embedded below.

What is a convertible note?

Convertible notes are debt instruments that converts in to equity, at a later date. The lender initially gives a loan with an understanding that he can convert these in to equity. In most cases, this later date is the date of next valuation of the company. If there is no next round of valuation, the company should return the debt back to lender in a fixed time interval.

Convertible notes are quite popular in startup ecosystems like Silicon Valley in USA. In India, there are other forms of convertible instruments. Such as CCDS/CCPS (compulsorily convertible debenture or preference share). These are not exactly akin to convertible notes prevalent in valley.

Ministry of corporate affairs has announced acceptance of the convertible note as a concept for startups through a circular no. G.S.R. 639(E) New Delhi, dated 29th June, 2016.

What is the new in the recent announcement?

In existing CCD/CCP instruments, company receiving funds upfront enters into an agreement defining the value or a formula at which these will convert in to equity. This value, at which they will convert cannot be lower than the present fair market value. The CCD or CCP are compulsorily convertible if there is a next round of valuation in a specified period. If there is no valuation in that period, then the money raised remains as a simple loan to be repaid.

The convertible note practice in valley is better placed. There also, a convertible note is also a loan given by investor to company. The difference being, the lender gets an advantage to convert debt to equity at a later date at a discounted rate.

So if a Rs.10 share value at later date is Rs. 50, the lender may get a conversion at Rs. 40. Next valuation round may also happen at lower than present fair market value.

So, this seems more of less like similar, what is the problem then?

The anomaly is that the Indian company can raise funds using convertible notes from Indian lenders only, and not from foreign investors.

RBI does not allow valuation linked convertibles notes. iSPIRT approached RBI with this stay-in-India check list item. RBI felt that there has to be an acceptance in company law for the convertible note concept, as akin to the practice in developed world.

iSPIRT approached ministry of corporate affairs (MCA), and the new announcement is a step forward in this direction. We soon expect RBI to follow suit and permit convertible notes from foreign investors.

Are there any conditions in MCA announcement?

MCA has announced a definition for “convertible notes” under G.S.R. 639(E) by amending the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 2014. You can read the complete circular here.

The limitations are:

a) The provision of Convertible note applies only to Startups
b) The amount has to be 25 lakhs or more

As per circular the definition of convertible note is added as follows:
“convertible note” means an instrument evidencing receipt of money initially as a debt, which is repayable at the option of the holder, or which is convertible into such number of equity shares of the start-up company upon occurrence of specified events and as per the other terms and conditions agreed to and indicated in the instrument.

iSPIRT stand

iSPIRT will actively pursue this further with RBI.

DIPP and MCA have taken an appreciable step forward, in getting the regulation relaxed for DIPP registered Startups.

However, in order to bring the Indian startup ecosystem at par with developed world, the limitation to DIPP registered Startups should not exist. These measures are to be adopted for all startups/companies across country.

Posted on

Stay-In-India Checklist – Successes So Far And The Path Forward

Over the past few months, we have witnessed a number of policy changes focused on creating a conducive environment for startups and entrepreneurship in India. Some changes go beyond the startup ecosystem and attempt to resolve the issues faced by companies/investors in general. A common feature in most such changes is iSPIRT’s Stay-in-India Checklist (SIIC). The SIIC comprises 34 issues, which were extracted from a larger list of 120+ issues, put together by the iSPIRT team after extensive consultation with various stakeholders.

With the 29th June notification of the MCA amending the Deposit Rules, a total of 29 SIIC issues have been addresses/acknowledged by various government departments. Some of the key changes that have taken place pursuant to SIIC are as follows:

  • Angel tax: Monies received by a company from certain resident investors (including angel investors) which are in excess of the fair market value of shares issued against such monies, are taxed as income in the hands of such company. This leads to significant hurdles in domestic angel investments (other popular modes of investments are exempted from this tax). Now, startups that are approved by the inter-ministerial board formed by DIPP (“Approved Startups”) have been exempted from this requirement.
  • Harmonisation of tax policy for listed and unlisted equity instruments: There is unnecessary disparity between holding periods for listed and unlisted shares for claiming long term capital gains benefit in relation to them. While the holding period for listed shares is only 12 months, for unlisted shares, it was 36 months. This, despite the fact that investment in unlisted shares, such as those of startups, carry higher risk. Now, this period has been reduced to 24 months. This relaxation is available to all companies, irrespective of them being startups.
  • Favourable tax regime for IPR: In the past several years, India has experienced that the ownership of IPR created in India does not reside in India, as tax regime for IPR in other jurisdictions is more favourable. Now, income by way of royalty in respect of a patent developed and registered in India will be taxed at 10%. This relaxation is available to all companies, irrespective of them being startups.
  • Convertible notes: One of the most popular instruments abroad for startups to raise early stage funds, convertible note, is not expressly recognised in India, and could be considered to be a form of ‘deposit’ which can be taken by a company only from its existing shareholders/ directors. Now, convertible notes of up to INR 25 lakhs per person have been permitted for startups that have registered on the StartupIndia portal (“Registered Startups”).
  • Indemnity escrows and deferred consideration: In FDI transactions, use of escrow mechanisms for indemnity arrangements and payment of deferred consideration required prior approval of the RBI. This created significant hurdles in acquisition of Indian companies by non-residents (since these terms are standard in acquisition transactions globally, and all acquires expected them in Indian acquisitions as well). Now, these mechanisms have been permitted for a period of up to 18 months and for an amount of up to 25% of the consideration under the automatic route (without the prior approval of the RBI). This relaxation is available to all companies, irrespective of them being startups.
  • Transfer from FVCI to non-resident: There is uncertainty around the transfer of shares of an Indian company by an FVCI entity to a non-resident entity. While certain custodians allow such a transfer without an approval of the RBI, other custodians require prior approval of the RBI before proceeding with such transfer. Although there is no specific regulation that requires FVCI entities to obtain prior approval of the RBI for such transfers, given the aforesaid difference of opinion among custodian (which results in delays in M&A transactions), there was a need for the RBI to clarify this issue. Now, Registered Startups have been exempted from this requirement.
  • Restriction on FVCIs from investing in all sectors: Foreign venture capital investors (FVCIs) are permitted to invest in only certain specified sectors. This is largely owing to the list of permitted sectors set out in registration certificates issued by authorities to FVCIs. Now, FVCIs are permitted to invest in all Registered Startups, regardless of the sectors they have been engaged in.

In addition to the above, the following issues have also been recognised by various government departments. The changes to resolve these issues have either been notified, or have been announced to be notified in due course:

  • Collection of foreign monies by residents in India on behalf of non-residents
  • Online filing of forms for cross border transactions
  • Simplification of incorporation process
  • Share swaps in FDI transactions
  • Venture debt not be categorised as deposits
  • Acquisition of overseas company with an existing subsidiary in India
  • Foreign subsidiaries of Indian companies investing back into India
  • Relaxation of external commercial borrowing guidelines for startups
  • Simplifying process of conversion of LLP into a company
  • Exclusion of private companies from the term ‘listed company’
  • Grant of ESOPs to promoters and independent directors
  • Single window agency for closure of failed startups
  • Permitting outbound mergers
  • Simplifying the process of private placement
  • Applicability of provisions relating to insider trading on private companies

As one would note, a significant number of material issues have either been addressed or are in advanced stage of being addressed. iSPIRT continues to interact with the government to get further relaxations on these issues, as some relaxations are restricted only to Approved Startups or Recognised Startup, or are simply limited in scope. iSPIRT also continues to push for resolution of other issues which have either not been addressed so far or are new and have not been covered in SIIC.