Beyond the clutter: How OCEN is unlocking MSME credit market in India

Introduction

OCEN plays a pivotal role in revolutionising MSME lending in India. This innovative open network is specifically designed to serve those new to credit, employing an omni-channel approach that democratises and simplifies access to lending.

Currently, the market lacks a scalable and profitable model for short-term, low-value MSME loans – a significant gap that OCEN has adeptly filled with its GeM-SAHAY pilots.

Amidst the confusion and excitement surrounding OCEN versus ONDC, and the broader impact of open networks in the lending sphere, this blog aims to provide clarity and insight. Let’s dive in and explore these transformative developments.

🔀 OCEN or ONDC: Which is better for short tenure MSME lending?

There’s much debate about which lending framework potential partners should explore. Rahul Mathur (Associate Director, InsuranceDekho) captures this perfectly in his tweet, presented as a checklist below:

🗣️ “Turns out, the focus in lending for ONDC v/s OCEN is very different (see the image below)
(1) 💰Type of loan: Type 1 personal loan v/s Type 4 MSME loan
(2) 🔎GTM: Online v/s Omni-channel (assisted)
(3) 🙇Persona: Eligible for credit v/s New to credit
(4) 🌟Objective: Bring credit to point of commerce v/s Democratize credit access

To summarize, there are some good reasons why ONDC has launched loans independently of the OCEN network.
Over time, OCEN will expand to include further lending use-cases & products. And, at that point, ONDC <> OCEN interoperability would make sense.”

You can find the original post here

Clearly, OCEN is the undisputed option for short tenure, low ticket size lending for new to credit MSMEs. Over time the lending use cases will be expanded to service the traditional form of loans.

OCEN and ONDC, while both operating in the lending space, are tailored for very different use cases and audiences. While they may overlap in some cases, the larger ecosystem benefits from introduction of newer networks. In the end, it’s all about solving the most challenging problems 🙂

Let’s further understand how OCEN addresses the MSME lending problem in India.


📈 OCEN makes small ticket size lending a reality

OCEN’s primary goal is to make short-term lending profitable. Something which we’ve achieved in our pilots with the Government e-Marketplace, through the GeM-SAHAY app.

One of our volunteers explains the economics in this blog post: Evaluating the short term lending opportunity, where he shows how lenders can earn 2.2x higher revenue with the same capital through the adoption of the OCEN framework.

The significant 2.2x increase in revenue is attributed to the introduction of a crucial role known as the borrower’s agent. These agents not only reduce the cost of servicing a loan but also heighten accountability within the system.

Borrower’s Agents (BAs) assume a variety of roles traditionally outsourced by lenders, BAs function as data providers, collections agents, escrow account managers, and product providers.

By integrating these services and cohesively binding the network, BAs enable lenders to efficiently service low-cost loans even in remote areas. In performing these four key roles, the borrower’s agent emerges as the cornerstone of the open network, vital for its effective operation.

The role of borrower’s agent has been discussed in depth in one of our open house sessions:

OCEN is changing the game by making even the tiniest loans worthwhile for both the lender and the borrower.


🌐 Efficacy of Open networks and streamlining the lending process

Some people we’ve spoken to, worry that open networks will lead to the commodification of lending, which, in turn, is bad for the overall market. However, this couldn’t be farther from the truth 🙂.

OCEN streamlines the lending process by introducing roles such as the borrower’s agent, KYC agents, and collection partners. These roles combine to create a bundle that lenders can easily integrate into their processes to start lending.

Newer and smaller lenders will benefit from the transparency and scale offered by open networks.

Closed network auctions, which are common today, see lenders bidding down for loans. However, their lack of transparency and scale often results in low profitability.

Open networks, on the other hand, provide scale and transparency that leads to low cost of servicing, more borrowers to choose from, and reliability in the system through a borrower’s agent.

Larger lenders benefit from the low cost of servicing a loan that comes with open networks

Larger lenders will benefit from open networks as it provides the technical chops of a borrower’s agent. BAs can help with KYC, collections and other parts of servicing a loan while absorbing some of the costs.

We’ve seen such effects before, with the introduction of Aadhaar and UPI, where KYC and collections became far cheaper enabling large lenders to facilitate smaller ticket size loans.

In conclusion

Through OCEN, the potential to unlock a ~$300 billion credit market in India becomes a tangible reality. This is demonstrated by the increased revenue potential and the introduction of the borrower’s agent role, enhancing loan servicing efficiency and accountability.

Moreover, OCEN’s streamlined lending process benefits the entire market, by offering scalability and cost-effectiveness to both emerging and established lenders.

Thus, embracing OCEN is not just a choice but a strategic direction for expanding market possibilities and empowering both lenders and borrowers in the dynamic credit landscape of India.

OCEN 4.0 : Intro to Lenders Openhouse #11

📢Calling all lenders to understand how a short tenor loan can become both an effective and profitable business opportunity under OCEN 4.0. 🔑📈

If you are a lender looking for the next big opportunity in lending to the thousands of MSMEs currently unable to access loans, then don’t miss this introduction to OCEN 4.0. 💡

Here we deep-dive into how a new underwriting model enabled by OCEN 4.0 makes it viable and profitable to provide loans to MSMEs traditionally considered unfavourable candidates for loans given the associated high delinquency rates.
Our OCEN pilots show, in some cases, it is even possible to create short tenor loans that are twice as profitable as long tenor loans. 🌟🚀🚀

OCEN Documentation: http://ocen.dev

❓Questions? Submit your questions here.
📩Contact? Reach the OCEN 4.0 team at [email protected]

Please note: The blog post is authored by our volunteers, Sagar Parikh and Rahul Bhaik

OCEN 4.0: Intro to Borrowers Agent Openhouse 10

📢Calling all loan agents keen to understand the OCEN 4.0 business opportunity. 🔑📈

OCEN 4.0  introduces a new and powerful role – the Borrowers Agent(BA). If you are looking to play a pivotal role in the MSME lending ecosystem without lending from your own balance sheet, this new role of a BA may be what you want to understand really well. 💡

The BA role is critical to the OCEN story. In this session, we deep-dive on what this role entails, why it is the linchpin of the OCEN 4.0 model, how BAs enable lenders to go remote, and how this role wields a lot of power. We also talk through how to get started, possible business models for BAs and what to focus on to be a successful Borrowers Agent. 🌟🚀🚀

OCEN Documentation: http://ocen.dev

❓Questions? Submit your questions here.
📩Contact? Reach the OCEN 4.0 team at [email protected]

Please note: The blog post is authored by our volunteers, Wribhu Tyagi and Aravind R.

OCEN 4.0 : Tech deep-dive Openhouse #9

📢👷🧑‍💻Calling all TSPs and participants eager to dive into OCEN 4.0 APIs. 

If you are wanting to understand the tech, the APIs and get started on building for OCEN 4.0, our second open house on OCEN 4.0 is here for you !! 💡

In this session, we do a deep-dive on the architecture, the loan journey on OCEN 4.0 components, the APIs in the OCEN spec and share how you can build for a participant by mocking the APIs of the other. 📝🔑🧑‍💻

OCEN Documentation: http://ocen.dev

❓Questions? Submit your questions here.
📩Contact? Reach the OCEN 4.0 team at [email protected]

Please note: The blog post is authored by our volunteers, Aravind R and Sagar Parikh.

Introducing OCEN 4.0: Transforming MSME Lending 🚀🚀

We’re thrilled to unveil OCEN 4.0, the latest advancement in our Open Credit Enablement Network protocol, revolutionizing cash flow-based MSME lending. 🌟

OCEN 4.0 represents a significant leap forward from our ongoing GeM SAHAY and GST SAHAY pilots. In this iteration, along with updated API specifications, we have also added the OCEN Registry, Product Network and rules, specialized participant roles and much more. All these features help us unlock cash-flow-based lending to match the scale, complexity and needs of Bharat. 🔑📈

Check out our introductory open house session on OCEN 4.0

🔍 More details? The API and documentation of OCEN 4.0 are publicly available at http://ocen.dev and will be updated with FAQs from the open house sessions.

🔮 What’s next? Yes, a lot is happening. We have more open house sessions coming out in the following weeks. We are also actively onboarding Wave 1 partners for OCEN 4.0.

❓Questions? Submit your questions here.
📩Contact? Reach the OCEN 4.0 team at [email protected]

Please note: The blog post is authored by our volunteers, Aravind R and Sagar Parikh.

Volunteer Hero: Amit Ranjan

“That will never work!”

To iSPIRT volunteers, those four words are a rallying cry. Words that make us intrepid souls smile with a quiet confidence and inspire an iron will to get the job done. The best among us turn those words into their life’s work by building systems that serve millions of Indians. 

iSPIRT’s best work has been in building digital public goods for India. This work is inevitably anchored by a volunteer who selflessly serves the mission; with a relentlessness and belief that could wring water from stone. Today, we celebrate one such volunteer hero: Amit Ranjan.

He had just sold his startup SlideShare to LinkedIn and had set a high watermark for products built in India for the world. After a successful exit, unlike what many others in his position might have done, Amit took the less travelled path of working within the government. Contrary to what one might imagine, even in his new role, Amit crackled with an energy that promised to single-handedly drag government departments into the future; and his eyes would sparkle as he showed you a demo of what would eventually become one of the pillars of India Stack: DigiLocker.

India Stack was built to enable a presenceless, paperless, and cashless society. Aadhaar and UPI were instrumental in enabling presenceless and cashless transactions. DigiLocker is another piece of the puzzle. Amit rolled up his sleeves, joined MeitY, and architected a national federated data and document network for India’s ~1.5 billion citizens. 

Today, DigiLocker functions as an interoperable public-private ecosystem for paperless service delivery by digitizing citizen records and enabling their digital usage. Documents and certificates issued by different government agencies such as Aadhaar, PAN Card, Driving License, and even school and college certificates are available today on DigiLocker. The system Amit helped build has led to increased transparency, reduced bureaucracy, and significant cost savings for both private and public sector organizations.

Nearly 15 crore Indians are already DigiLocker users today, using 5.6 billion documents issued by almost 2,500 issuing entities. The impact is felt even in the mundane daily activities like checking into an airport or showing your driver’s license using DigiLocker during a routine traffic stop. And the system is just getting started.

Those who have worked with Amit in the government (like Abhishek Singh IAS, President & CEO NeGD; MD & CEO Digital India Corporation (DIC); CEO Karmayogi Bharat; at Govt of India) sing his praises the same as us. To quote Mr Singh, “Amit Ranjan is a Hero. I believe that we need to celebrate the Heroes and the teams that go into building these Digital Public Goods”.

Creating impact like this on a national scale through sheer grit and commitment inspires every single iSPIRT volunteer. And that’s why we choose to recognize and celebrate Amit with iSPIRT’s highest commendation; To us, he truly is a “Volunteer Hero”!

By Sharad Sharma, Dr Renuka Garg, Shoaib Ahmed and Pankaj Jaju for Volunteer Fellow Council

NavIC Grand Challenge Launched by Shri Piyush Goyal, Union minister on 17th May 2022

At the Fourth National Startup Advisory Council Meet held on 17.05.2022 under Hon’ble Minister of Commerce and Industry, Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, and Textiles Shri Piyush Goyal, the NavIC Grand Challenge (GC) was launched. The GC seeks to mainstream the use of NavIC and establish it as a domestic mapping solution.

iSPIRT has contributed to the development of this Grand Challenge. During the Third NSAC Meet, Sharad Sharma, Co-founder of iSPIRT and a member of the National Startup Advisory Council (NSAC), proposed the concept of prominence to NavIC as a domestic mapping solution.

Later, the iSPIRT Team, led by Captain Amit Garg and our volunteers Sayandeep Purkayastha, Captain George Thomas, and Tanuvi Thakur, presented the concept note and working paper on the GC to DPIIT (Dept for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade). 

Multiple rounds of discussion among the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade, Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), and iSPIRT Foundation brought the final shape to the working paper. All of this culminated in the launch of GC-NavIC on the 17th of May.

What is NavIC?

NavIC or Navigation of Indian Constellation is India’s independent regional satellite navigation system created by DOS/ISRO. Its signals are inter-operable with the civilian signals of the other navigation satellite systems namely GPS, Galileo, Glonass, and BeiDou. NavIC has made in-roads into civilian applications in India like vehicle tracking, power grid synchronization, location-based services (using mobile phones), disaster alert dissemination, etc. Efforts are being made to enable the incorporation of NavlC into drones, the maritime sector, wearable devices, time dissemination, geodesy, etc. The applications are being promoted by the availability of NavlC-enabled off-the-shelf chipsets & devices at competitive rates and by the adoption of NavlC in national and international industry standards.

The GC is a step towards taking NavIC adoption further into the future, i.e. the future of AtmaNirbhar Mapping Solution. The GC brings together the triumvirate of NavIC, Agriculture, and Drones by becoming a big-bang thrust for the Kisan Drones Project as well.

The GC-NavIC

The GC-NavIC has an intersection with GOI’s Project Drone Shakti. It seeks to promote:

  1. The use of drones to solve the problem of agriculture insurance, i.e., the integration of the product to solve cases under the Pradhan Mantri Fassal Bima Yojana, is in line with the Government’s steps to harness technology for agricultural growth;
  2. Building a digital database of agricultural data that will supplement the digitization of land records and crop assessment measures of Drone Shakti;
  3. The use of ISRO’s homegrown NavIC technology in developing drones under the GC will promote the use of NavIC in the commercial drone landscape for remote sensing, imagery, mapping, etc.

The GC has invited innovative solutions that will utilize NavIC-enabled drones to capture data related to farm field topography, process this data, and make it available for use for commercial purposes. Ideas should be such that the product can be deployed across all terrain types in the country. Further, the captured and processed data should be viable and efficient for use within the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) framework. 

A detailed application process (here) calls for a detailed proposal of the tech specs of the participants’ product solution. This will be the basis for 25 participants selected for a presentation of their product before the Experts Panel. 7 selected participants on the basis of an objective and transparent selection criteria will compete in Phase 1 of the GC – the prototype deployment stage. In phase 2, the top 3 participants will compete towards fulfilling the problem statement by deploying their fully functioning product.

Transformative Powers of Challenge Grants

Challenge Grants have transformative powers and scalability opportunities that can serve as an impetus to quality innovation. Treatment Adherence for TB was the first challenge launched under the Grand Challenges in TB Control program. The aim was to devise solutions for improving tuberculosis screening, detection, and treatment outcomes. One of the participants, 99Dots, came up with a novel solution for low-cost monitoring and medication adherence program by using a combination of basic mobile phones and augmented blister packaging to provide real-time medication monitoring at a drastically reduced cost. By 2017-18, 99Dots was used across all districts in India and is now listed as a treatment program on the Government’s Nikshay portal.

The GC-NavIC through its intersection with Project Drone Shakti and the revamped operational guidelines of the PMFBY that emphasize tech-based solutions will help harness technology for agriculture and create opportunities for commercial utilization of NavIC. The recent ban on foreign drones by the Government will move the focus to domestic manufacturing. Encouraging local drones with local technology will increase the AtmaNirbhar potential in the drone and navigation ecosystem and enable Indian Startups to unlock the $5 billion drone market.

Conclusion

The GC-NavIC is touted to deliver three essential outcomes – better regulations in the drone and mapping space, ecosystem development, and channel of public money for private innovation.  All three will lead to transformative innovations that will push India into modern agricultural practices and domestic mapping-navigation solutions.

The post is authored by our volunteer fellow, Tanuvi Thakur. She can be reached at [email protected]. 

Can digital currencies and crypto investors help close India’s SME financing gap?

The internet connected the average Indian to millions of sources of information. Could crypto protocols connect Indians to millions of sources of capital?

To achieve its goal of a five trillion dollar economy by 2025, India needs to close an enormous financing gap for its small and medium-size enterprises (SMEs). It already has important assets with which to attract global capital: the youth of its population, the energy of its tech sector, the growth of its internet connectivity, and the rising acceptance of so-called informational collateral in lieu of traditional physical collateral. But what hasn’t yet been done is to integrate these assets into the new multi-trillion dollar cryptoeconomy, which may have the most risk-tolerant, internationally oriented, growth-seeking pool of investors in the world.

In this piece we begin by reviewing India’s need for SME and startup capital. We then tick through India’s existing assets, with particular focus on informational collateral, which combines the previously separate concepts of due diligence and physical collateral into an internet-friendly financing package. Finally, we discuss why global crypto investors could help meet India’s capital needs.

India’s need for SME and startup financing

India is home to more than 60 million businesses, 10 million of which have unique GST registration numbers, most of them SMEs. However, of the one trillion USD worth of total commercial lending exposure of the banking system, only ~25% of it is provided to SMEs, which are considered less creditworthy than larger corporates or multinationals. This has resulted in a financing gap estimated to be between 250-500 billion USD, where meritorious businesses without national profiles aren’t able to access the capital they need to finance their growth. India’s next trillion in GDP growth depends upon solving this problem, but the incumbent financial system may not have the resources to fix it alone. Despite ever-increasing bank branches, India’s legacy financial system is still slow, costly, and unwieldy for borrowers— in sharp contrast to the databases, online KYC systems and intelligent lending apps of new-age fintech companies. And in addition to this high cost of capital for MSMEs, India also has a low baseline level of financial inclusion.

The baseline issue is being partially addressed with low-frill Jan Dhan accounts, which are providing partial banking support for millions of previously excluded individuals. Many of these Jan Dhan accounts are held by small businesses, entrepreneurs, students and self-employed people in rural India, the same folks who are running India’s SMEs. But these accounts have only inflow data, with outflows typically in cash. Even though cash still plays a big role in the self-organized and informal sectors, it’s not easy to provide business-related financing in cash. The so-called JAM trinity (Jan Dhan accounts, Aadhaar digital identities, and Mobile phones) offers a partial solution for this under-banked population, but it only supports what we might think of as consumer-grade applications like basic peer-to-peer payments and individual savings accounts. Access to capital sufficient to finance a business — a true measure of financial inclusion — is still not yet present for these low-income, mostly feature-phone possessing groups.

On the other end of the spectrum from rural SMEs are India’s tech startups. Over the last decade, India has broken into the ranks of global technology and is now the #3 generator of unicorns in the world. Supportive governmental policies, combined with a young, creative, and aspirational workforce has helped reimagine large swathes of the economy including diverse industries such as e-commerce, logistics, SAAS, education, food, healthcare etc. This rise has attracted global equity and loan-funds that could in turn help many start-ups become world beating players in their respective domains. But the startup sector is just as hungry for capital as the rural SMEs, and India’s startup economy is still somewhat disconnected from global venture capitalists and financial markets.

India’s assets: youth, growth, connectivity, and informational collateral

India does have assets with which to close the capital gap. It has a youthful population. It has a fast-growing economy, even given the setbacks of COVID-19. It has an enormous population of hundreds of millions of new internet users. And it has something new, which is the possibility of informational collateral as a sort of combination of traditional concepts of due diligence and physical collateral.

Specifically, the SME funding gap is most pressing for the Indian cash-flow businesses that don’t have the physical assets to take out loans, which are the mainstay of the current, hard-collateral-backed credit system.

One alternative is to use trustworthy digital records to ascertain whether a business is worthy of credit or equity investment. India’s Goods and Services Tax (GST) helps to address this by generating invoice and payment data in a format suitable for credit underwriting and risk analysis. The GST data also enables a small enterprise in a large value system to provide data and visibility across the supply chain; for example, one can track the progress of parts from a small parts supplier to an auto component manufacturer to a large passenger car maker all the way through to distributors, sub-dealers, and retail sales.

The digital version of an SME’s sales and purchase invoices ledger thus amounts to informational collateral on both the company and the larger ecosystem within which it sits, that could become the basis for extending credit, as an alternative to the hard asset or collateral-based financial system. This is similar to how Square Capital and Stripe Capital already function in the West.

In addition to credit-based financing, the trustworthy records furnished by GST’s informational collateral can also support equity or quasi-equity financing, to support growth without increasing debt. These might take the form of direct equity investments in small businesses, or even personal micro-equity investments in individual consultants or students. 

India’s innovation: use new pools of crypto capital to address long-standing financing needs

So, we understand that (a) Indian SMEs need capital, and that (b) IndiaStack’s UPI and Aadhaar can help GST generate informational collateral for potential investors and lenders.


Now the question arises: what class of investors is most willing to use this newfangled type of informational collateral to invest in potentially high-risk businesses outside of the proven venues of America, Europe, East Asia and the large Indian enterprises? Who are the most risk-tolerant, international, forward-looking, class of investors in the world — willing to risk millions of dollars purely on the basis of internet diligence alone?

It may turn out to be the new class of wealthy, globally-minded crypto investors. After all, the 10-year old cryptoeconomy is now worth trillions of dollars, there are more than a hundred million crypto holders around the world, and there are at least fifty crypto protocols valued over one billion dollars, a “unicoin” analog to the traditional tech unicorn. While still small in comparison to global capital markets, a sector worth $2T that is growing at more than 100% per annum could become a much larger piece of the global financial puzzle in short order. This is a new source of risk-tolerant digital capital that could flow into India to help close the SME financing gap, if we can make it an attractive proposition for the global investor.

Specifically, India could offer a viable path to deploy this new crypto wealth in a controlled manner, while solving for SME financial inclusion. Inflows of cryptocurrencies from KYC-ed investors through approved Indian and global exchanges can potentially be allowed into India for the purposes of enhancing SME access to low-cost global capital. GST-registered companies could, for instance, receive capital against their issued e-invoices and other information collateral in special accounts opened via a controlled conduit such as GIFT city, which is one of India’s favored bridges to international markets. The companies benefiting will need to explicitly consent to sharing their information and receiving funds into a new account at system-level while capturing cash flows against invoices for repayment. Inflows of global crypto-capital into Indian SMEs could also enable the rest of the credit system to migrate to informational collateral-based lending. And the special account could eventually be ported to a wallet backed by a national digital currency, such as the proposed digital rupee.

For more detail on this possibility, we invite your attention to Balaji S. Srinivasan’s companion piece on the subject, where he proposes to Add Crypto To IndiaStack. Balaji makes the case for crypto-powered extension of IndiaStack, which broadens IndiaStack from its current mostly domestic remit into an international platform for attracting capital from around the world. He describes several case studies by which the emerging world of decentralized finance or “defi” could help enrich the Indian economy, without competing with the digital rupee. For example, Indian startups could benefit from crypto crowdfunding, Indian SMEs as discussed could access global defi lending pools, and Indian students might even be funded with the emerging concept of personal tokens, like an equity-based version of microfinance. As the former CTO of  Coinbase, the $100B crypto goliath, and a former General Partner at Andreessen Horowitz, the $16B venture capital firm, Balaji’s proposals have technical and social support from the very class of investors we’d seek to attract. At least insofar as they relate to the issue of plugging the SME financing gap, we believe they deserve serious consideration by policymakers in India. 

In short, India has a unique opportunity to close the SME financing gap by attracting the new class of global crypto investors, by using everything the IndiaStack team has helped build over the last decade — particularly UPI, Aadhaar, GST, and the informational collateral they generate —  to help connect the trillion-dollar cryptoeconomy to capital-hungry Indian entrepreneurs.


The blog post is co-authored by Sanjay Phadke, Krishna V Iyer, Pankaj Gupta, Sanjay Jain, Sharad Sharma and Siddharth Shetty.

For any further queries, please write to [email protected]

Open House Session #1 on iSPIRT’s Balloon Volunteering

We held an impromptu Open Session on Balloon Volunteering on 20th September 2020. Watch the recorded video and presentation below to learn if iSPIRT volunteering is right for you.

This session will cover some of the available volunteer opportunities and tell you how to engage with us.

Open House on iSPIRT Balloon Volunteering from ProductNation/iSPIRT

In case you want to explore Balloon Volunteering with iSPIRT, we request you to fill out the form here: bit.ly/iSPIRTForm

iSPIRT Foundation’s Official Response to Non-Personal Data Report

Last month, an expert committee chaired by Kris Gopalakrishnan submitted a report on a framework for regulating Non-Personal Data in India. The rest of this blogpost contains iSPIRT’s response to this report.

At iSPIRT Foundation, our view on data laws stems from three fundamental beliefs: 

  1. Merits of a data democracy (that is, the user must be in charge),
  2. Competitive effects must be well understood, for creation of a level playing field amongst all Indian companies, and some ring-fencing must exist to protect against global data monopolies
  3. Careful design enables both high compliance and high convenience

It is with these three perspectives that we have analyzed the Non-Personal Data report in our response. 

The report makes a well-cited and articulate case for regulating data in India, such that “[data’s] benefits accrue to India, and Indians”. It defines and outlines the roles of various entities relating to the capture, processing and governance of Non-Personal Data. Whereas we are wholeheartedly aligned with the vision of the committee and its members in creating an Aatmanirbhar Bharat and the importance of facilitating a robust AI-industry in the country, we find that the report is sound in premise but murky in detail. Where an overarching legal framework surrounding NPD is proposed, on closer inspection it falls short of achieving the aforementioned goals of protection for Indians and prosperity for Indian businesses. Therefore, more work must be done before a final version of this report can be released. 

In what follows, we take the example of one industry that will be affected by the new Non-Personal Data framework and attempt to understand the report in relation to it. 

Case Study: X-ray Data

Consider the case of a (fictional) health-tech startup called rad.ai that seeks to generate radiology summaries from lung X-rays. These summaries will help pulmonologists (lung-specialist doctors) identify various pulmonary diseases or early signs of cancer. Such a company requires two things to succeed – data about X-rays and technology to build models. 

Under the tenets of the NPD report, it would seem that (given the right technology foundations) such a startup would be well placed to succeed. In particular, the report suggests that the X-ray data as described above will be classified as community data and outlines mechanisms for collecting and sharing it. It suggests that the dual goal of enabling rad.ai while protecting the subjects of the data can be accomplished in the following framework – 

  1. rad.ai will first be able to identify that appropriately anonymized lung X-rays, termed community data, are available for access through meta-data that is published by radiology labs engaging in collecting such data. 
  2. rad.ai will then be able to access this data for free through a data trust (presumably a virtual API on the cloud) which is created by the radiology labs. 
  3. This will all happen with the consent and oversight of a data trustee, an entity that is a representative of the persons from whom this data is collected. 

While this sets a broad-strokes framework with the right intentions, there are a few key problems that arise when we dive deeper into the proposed solution. We have outlined some areas where clarifications are needed and details must be made available. These include the definition & value of community data, obligations of the data custodian, access for data users and rights of the data principal. Towards the end, we also discuss the question of NPD’s interplay with personal data and the definition and use of public data. 

Definition and Value of Community Data 

While the case of X-ray data seems straightforward, the scope of community data in the report appears to be vast. However, it also seems to suggest that while data explicitly extracted from users is classified as community data, data generated in the course of a business’s activities may be considered private business data – and this may not be mandated to be shared. In that case, it would appear that e-commerce, delivery and employee data fall under private business data – although an argument could be made for classifying this as community data. 

Further, the report makes a distinction between raw and processed data. In particular, raw data must be shared free of cost, whereas the price of processed data could be determined based on market or FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) principles. In the case of lung X-ray data, labs obtain such data from anonymizing raw personal data, so presumably it is now processed and need not be shared without remuneration. In the general case, however, we recommend that the lines between raw and (various levels of) processed data should be clearly demarcated. 

Data Custodian Perspective

Consider next, the situation from the perspective of the diagnostic labs. There are about 70,000 labs and hospitals offering radiology services in the country [ref]. Each of these has its own technology implementations or third-party TSPs (technical service providers) for collecting and storing any patient data. How can all of these labs and hospitals be mandated to provide control of this data to the data trustee in order to share the X-ray information with companies like rad.ai? Who is/are the data trustee in this case anyway – the MoHWF, the NHA, an NGO serving the interests of cancer patients? If there are multiple data trustees that have an interest in the same underlying data, how is it ensured that every decision that each of them takes is in the best interests of the user? How are labs supposed to even publish the meta-data (meta-information about what data they have collected) in a standard, machine-readable format, so that companies like rad.ai can discover it seamlessly? Finally, considering that such compliance comes with associated costs, what are the concrete benefits for making this data available?

Data User Perspective

Then there is the case of rad.ai itself. Let us assume, for now, the provisions of the previous paragraph and overlook the contentions raised. Say that because of access to this X-ray data, the startup rad.ai has been able to create excellent ML models to predict the early risks of major diseases and help pulmonologists. It has done well and begins to expand across the country. A few years later, a foreign health-tech giant (again, fictional) called Hooli enters the fray by investing in rad.ai. Backed by foreign investment, rad is now stronger than ever. However, the report identifies “to promote and encourage the development of domestic industry and startups that can scale” as one of its key objectives. While rad.ai was originally a fully Indian company, it was allowed access to the community data from radiology labs to develop its models. Now that rad.ai has foreign investment, should it still be allowed to benefit from Indian community data? What if Hooli owns a majority stake? What if Hooli acquires rad.ai outright? 

Data Principal Perspective

Finally, consider this from the perspective of the patient herself – the “data principal”. How is she guaranteed that her interests are protected and the aforementioned data is impervious to de-anonymization? As discussed above health data is considered sensitive data and the patient has every right to ensure that it is handled with extreme care. The report also recommends that consent must be taken from the actors in the community before the anonymization and use of their data – but what form will this consent take? How will its purpose be determined and collection be enforced before any data is anonymized and utilized? How can anonymisation be assured when multiple anonymised datasets are capable of being combined together? Finally, the report acknowledges that all sharing of community data should be based on the concept of “beneficial ownership” where the benefits of this data sharing also accrue to the data principal. How is the patient directly benefiting from such a data-sharing mechanism? What mechanisms are in place to enable such benefits?  

Interplay With PDP Bill

Consider next, the case of the health-tech giant Hooli and assume that it also operates a search engine. As per the suggestions of the Srikrishna PDP Bill [Clause 14], Hooli could be allowed to collect personal user data and use it directly since its operation of search engines falls under “other reasonable uses of personal data”. When combined with the fact that under the provisions of the Non-Personal Data report sharing of all raw NPD becomes mandatory, Hooli is actually disincentivized from anonymizing its personal search data. By keeping this data personally identifiable, it is prevented from having to share it with competing search engines and startups. Can misaligned incentives such as these hinder progress towards the report’s stated goals? 

On Public Data

Consider finally that some of the labs and hospitals conducting X-rays will be government-owned. The report recommends that all data generated through government and government-funded activities are classified as Public data, which is in turn classified as a national resource. There is no guidance on the compliance requirements of the government controlling this public data under such a scenario. Will government hospitals still be required to make it available? More importantly, does the community (i.e. patients) have no claim to their data in this case merely because it was collected by the government instead of a private entity? 

Concluding Remarks

In summary, the report importantly conceives a legal notion of community, private and public non-personal data and outlines a framework in which such data might be shared for the advancement of economic, sovereign and core public interests. However, more work must be done to detail compliance requirements and standardize the mechanisms of sharing such data before the final version of the report is released. In its current state, the report only touches upon the rights of the data principal, the obligations of the data trustee and the compliance requirements of the data custodian. In a State with limited regulatory capacity for creating standards and enforcing bodies, these rights, obligations and compliance requirements should be comprehensively and clearly defined before a law ordaining them can come to pass. Custodians must be incentivized to share, industry startups must be enabled to access and the community must be empowered to self-preserve before the vision of an Aatmanirbhar Bharat with a booming AI industry can be realized. 


For further queries, drop us a note at [email protected]


India’s New Credit Rails

India is starved of affordable, formal credit. Only 11 % of the 60 million MSMEs* have access to capital from organised lenders today. This under-penetration has shackled our economic growth and economic woes of our growth drivers, the MSMEs has only worsened in wake of the current pandemic.

There is a massive market opportunity to be tapped here that has been inhibited because the current rails for flow of capital to the untapped market are broken. 

They are broken for the lenders, to be able to reach out to these prospective borrowers. Few of the many reasons include high cost of borrower acquisition and time consuming custom third party tie-ups with loan originators.

They are broken for the marketplaces to connect their customers with lenders. The custom integrations and manual processes are costly and time consuming. The Turnaround Time to get loans deposited to customers is high and their ability to provide custom financial products quickly is restricted, owing to implementation challenges.

These broken rails needed to be fixed and the solution must solve the problem at scale.

The fix for this is a ‘Fixed Line to Mobile Telephony’ moment for ‘Credit Borrower’.

In a complete re-imagination of the credit rails, we recently witnessed a loan disbursement :

  • Instantly in borrower’s bank account
  • From application to disbursement in less than 5 minutes, with no human decisioning involved!

The next chapter in the story of ‘India Stack’ that brought this to life is the new ‘Open Credit Enablement Network’. It is a common language for lenders and marketplaces to utilise and create innovative, financial credit products at scale.

In this new credit paradigm, the marketplaces/aggregators using these APIs to embed credit offerings in their applications are called ‘Loan Service Providers’ (LSPs).

  • How are these ‘Loan Service Providers’ playing a vital role in democratizing access to credit? 
  • How are they enabling more choices, better credit products and lower interest rates for their customers?
  • Why are they exuberant about this new ‘Plug and Play’ architecture and what does it mean for their core business and driving additional revenue?
  • What do they mean when they say ‘every marketplace will now become a Fintech company’?

Some of the top lenders in the country such as State Bank of India, HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, IDFC First Bank, Axis Bank and Bajaj Finserv have come onboard and will soon be in a state of readiness to usher in this new credit paradigm.

Just as UPI presented an opportunity for massive companies to be built and delightful customer experiences to be created, we are excited to see entrepreneurs capitalise on this massive opportunity.

We are excited to share with you :

  1. Answers to all the questions above
  2. A product demo depicting the ‘5-minute digital credit journey’ 
  3. Introduction to ‘Open Credit Enablement Network’

When: 5 pm to 6:30 pm, IST on Friday, 24th July

Where: Online virtual session on Zoom. Webinar details will be shared with the registered participants. 

To confirm your participation and receive the virtual link, please click here: https://bit.ly/LSPOpenHouse1 (same form has been embedded below)

____________________________________________________________

Recommended Reading :

Chapter 7 and 8 in RBI UK Sinha MSME committee report: https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/PublicationReportDetails.aspx?UrlPage=&ID=924

Introduction to India Stack’s fourth layer – Data Empowerment & Protection Architecture: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mW__azI8_ow

*Source – Ujjivan small finance Bank RHP & UK Sinha RBI MSME Committee Report

Announcement: iSPIRT Foundation & Japan’s IPA to work together on Digital Public Platforms

Information-technology Promotion Agency, Japan (IPA), Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO), and the Indian Software Product Industry Roundtable (iSPIRT) have shared common views that (i) our society will be transformed into a new digital society where due to the rapid and continued development of new digital technologies and digital infrastructure including digital public platforms, real-time and other data would be utilized for the benefit of people’s lives and industrial activities, (ii) there are growing necessities that digital infrastructure, together with social system and industrial platforms should be designed, developed and utilized appropriately for ensuring trust in society and industry along with a variety of engaged stakeholders and (iii) such well-designed digital infrastructure, social system and industrial platforms could have a great potential to play significant roles to improve efficiencies of societal services, facilitate businesses, realize economic development and solve social issues in many countries. 

Today, we affirm our commitment to launching our cooperation and collaboration through the bringing together of different expertise from each institution in the area of digital infrastructure, including mutual information sharing of development of digital infrastructure, in particular, periodic communication and exchange of views to enhance the capability of architecture design and establishment of digital infrastructure. We further affirm that as a first step of our cooperation, we will facilitate a joint study on digital infrastructure, such as (i) the situation of how such digital infrastructures have been established and utilized in India, Japan and/or other countries in Africa or other Asian regions (the Third Countries) as agreed among the parties, (ii) how the architecture was or can be designed for digital infrastructure as a basis for delivering societal services in the Third Countries and (iii) what kind of business collaboration could be realized, to review and analyze the possibility of developing digital infrastructure in the Third Countries through Japan-India cooperation. We may consider arranging a workshop or business matching as a part of the joint study to figure out realistic use cases.

Our cooperation is consistent with the “Japan-India Digital Partnership” launched between the Ministry of Economy Trade and Industry, Government of Japan and the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India in October 2018. We will work closely together and may consider working with other parties to promote and accelerate our cooperation if necessary.

For any clarification, please reach out to [email protected]